Monday, May 11, 2015

#130

http://www.eliteskills.com/analysis_poetry/Dream_Song_130_When_I_saw_my_friend_covered_with_blood_I_thought_by_John_Berryman_analysis.php

On a vision from a dream, one of those dreams that teach us what we really think. The dream vision is of a friend covered in blood, and it’s a wish that he would move on. It’s about success, apparent and real, about the relationship between the appearance of outward, worldly success and a life that more substantially makes somebody happy. I guess the spectacle of the miserable success is common enough. That’s what the “large strain of moving” means, I think—out doing what you do, book coming out in paperback (symbolic of successful life and career activity), but the activity just stretches him further on that rack of his own making. B. wishes all that quickening, life-supporting blood would flow away, leaving him “crisp.” (From the point of view of language and words? “Crisp” is a bull’s-eye. Wow. Nailed it. The image invokes dryness through loss of blood-moisture first, but also with an undertone of having been burned: He’s burned out.) He wishes the friend would bleed out, get it over with and dry up, which would actually be a mercy to someone whose life is a torment. You only wish this on someone if a) there is no hope of change in life, and b) you believe that the dying is not an end, but a change in itself, a continuance. But does maybe faith in an afterlife allow someone to abandon hope of change in this life a bit too easily? That’s the reason for the religious taboo against suicide, which has been religion’s way of addressing this issue. Your religious duty is to stick it out at all costs, play this life out to the last drop of blood.

B.’s not addressing that taboo at all, though. There’s a desire for death lurking here, and the final “spring up & go” is an ironic twist on what death often seems to be. Not an ending, a ceasing of life’s activity and motion; it’s the moment where you get up and finally start moving. It’s a faith in an afterlife all right, but I also can’t help seeing it as a rejection of life’s possibilities, a confirmation of despair. A poem like this, a dream vision, and an instructive one, is teaching, but it’s also doing something else: It looks like a preparation for suicide.

I’m not judging. Our whole society is edging slowly away from the orthodox Western taboo against willfully ending life—death with dignity, doctor-assisted suicide, unplugging the machines. Hospice. Disease, age, substance abuse: one of these will put each of us to the question. Facing that fact can ennoble death by leading us away from the fundamentalist fetish of clinging to life with absolute, unbending conviction, denying or enduring the torment of living if that’s what it has come to. On the other hand, it’s also wrong to make it too easy. Is this poem pushing for that? I only slightly suspect it, just a bit. But I get it. When the time comes to let go, let go. Still, dreaming that wish for someone else, in the end, may not only be a wish for his pain-releasing death. It may actually be a wish for his growth and change, yet, while there’s still time. So is this poem a death wish or a desire for growth? Doesn’t have to be one or the other. It’s both.

Sunday, May 10, 2015

#129

http://www.americanpoems.com/poets/john-berryman/5638

A dream, it seems. Triggered by an earlier experience? Perhaps. But may be just a dream.

But, this has me thinking about death, because B. wrote the poem and now I have to. There have been some moments when I was close by a death, but I’d rather keep them to myself.

Here’s how I want to think about death right now: The poet/artist Willliam Blake was with his brother when he died. He saw his spirit leave his brother’s body and rise up and out of the room—smiling and clapping his hands with joy. Blake, like most people of his time, was a firm, no-doubt believer in eternal life after death. This wasn’t just belief, this was a vision. He saw it. Blake had the gift, they say. On my trip to England last summer, we visited the Tate Britain gallery. I had wanted to see the Pre-Raphaelite paintings, but that wing of the gallery was closed for some work under way. I was disappointed. But what I didn’t know was that Tate Britain has a William Blake room, which more than made up for glimpses I was able to steal of the Rossetti paintings we originally went there for. Blake painted in watercolors, so they’re delicate and light-sensitive. Tate rotates them—a brief showing then back to the dark for years. By total chance, I got to see both of my two favorite watercolors by William Blake: His portrait of Isaac Newton, which was thrilling in itself, but even better was the portrait of the ghost of a flea, which is one of the creepiest images you’ll ever find anywhere. Blake was quite an amazing figure.

I’m not quite ready to uncritically swallow Blake’s vision and its message that fleas are inhabited by human souls who had possessed a bloodthirsty nature. There are more fleas alive in the world right now than humans who have ever lived anyway, so some of those bloodthirsty spirits would have to be doing double and triple duty inspiriting the fleas of the world. Blake himself was surprised by the image, though, with its monstrous human form, holding a cup to receive the blood he drinks. But so many people are convinced about life after death.

I have a good friend, an academic and writer and critic, who studies Appalachian folklore. She got to go to Paris as a grad student and present some research she had done, stories she had collected, about the common experience so many people have had of being visited by a loved one in a dream, especially a parent, once they’ve died. I had this experience as well, and I can say that it gave me a lot of comfort. My father—in the dream—is with his mother, my grandmother, and they’re at peace and they’re happy. There’s a doubting part of me that can still chalk this up to some kind of psychological self-hoodwinking, where the ego assuages its grief at the loss of a loved one with myths of an afterlife with God and other loved ones passed on. I’ll have a hard time ever totally letting go of this. But that hasn’t taken over either. A few dreams I’ve had have been more than the run-of-the-mill phantasms of the night our brains churn out to try and put our chaotic lives into some semblance of psychic of order. This was more. He told me to take care of my mom, and he was not sad or unhappy. Quite the opposite. I do kind of think after that that mom will join him one of these days—doesn’t have to be soon. He’s not experiencing time like we are if his spirit is indeed still consolidated in the afterlife, so he’s not in any hurry. Her life is lively as ever, perking along with energy and engagement. (Happy Mother’s day, Mom!) I don’t need to believe one way or another—we will die and our psychologies soothe that terror with myths of eternal life. Or, we live eternally. I can hold onto both for now.

Blake had no doubts about it. Neither does B., at least on the surface. The body is cold, and to touch it, even in a dream, is shocking. But he also states flat-out that “Christ waits.” The spirit will leave the body behind. That’s the problem for me: Eternal life absolutely supposes that those things of the spirit, the human aesthetic and the spark of empathy, the you-who-you-are reading your computer screen through your two bright eyes, these things are fundamentally apart from the body? I’m not quite so sure. Keats called it “negative capability,” the ability to hold two opposed ideas at the same time. In his words: “That is when man is capable of being in uncertainties. Mysteries, doubts, without any irritable reaching after fact and reason.”

So enough with the irritability of reason tonight. Blake painted Newton doubled over under the pitiless burden of his reason. Blake saw the ghosts of fleas walking the night, and Blake’s newly dead brother rose to heaven in ecstasy. In dreams, we drift to a place halfway between heaven and flesh.

Friday, May 8, 2015

#128

http://plagiarist.com/poetry/5708/

“So help me Jesus” is funny, if Good Friday is ever an occasion for humor. Good Friday always brings images of crucifixion to mind, which are just awful and make me squirm—that’s the point, of course. I was raised Catholic; I’m stuck with it. There’s the problem with bodies: On one hand they’re foundation for the mind/emotions/spirit, or all wrapped up with these wonderful things, and there’s the pleasures that come from having bodies, like sleep, sex, athletic health, a full belly, sensory wonders like Chanel N°5 in a woman’s hair, an oboe playing Mozart, the twittering of a house wren, Chagall’s stained glass in Rheims cathedral, and this chocolate muffin and good coffee I just finished for breakfast, and so many of the other gifts with which life festoons we physical humans. But then there’s crucifixion, being burned at the stake, not to mention the lesser parade of ills we more fortunate still must endure—hangnails, constipation, headaches, cuts and bruises, nausea, sore throats, acne, bee stings, diarrhea, yeast infections, hemorrhoids, sunburn, hemorrhages of the left ear, and columns more. We don’t necessarily die physically first, but that’s most often the case.

While we live, we have our senses. We have, for example, our ears. I have one that’s dimming, on the left side. No bleeding. I’ll get a hearing aid one of these day if I can ever afford a decent one, moving me one more step along the path to cyborg. If it takes a machine to keep me tuned in, then so be it: I’m grateful to live during a history when electric machines are following biochemical brains—eons behind, but on the move—up the road to complexity, with sentience the faraway destination and goal. The ear is a sensitive little machine itself, so it’s not so far-fetched that we might devise another machine to support its activity when an overworked bio-ear starts wearing down, the twitching responses of microscopic hairs and intimately imbricated nerve cells that rush information to our waiting nervous consciousness grow coarsened through the assaults of lifetimes of noise and poison. So isn’t it amazing how those murmurings we detect—snippets of dim language—resolve into voices that communicate: back-stabbing plots, embarrassing secrets, nasty gossip, confessions of misbehavior, plans and schemes, declarations of admiration, desire, love? Our intricate brains construct so much from such subtle nuance, and it takes a well-tuned set of sensitive ears to gather all that vibrational minutia. Working ears, like eyes and skin, start physical, then here it comes! Aggregations of form and meaning emerging, like radiant organizations of crystal forming out of dense chemical brine. We’re so miraculously sensitive. My cat trills once and I recognize her affection, knowing I may touch the softness of her luxurious fur. A lover signals with a barely audible mmmm… inviting that next touch. Please. Songbirds in the morning stake out the space and pattern and relationships of their lives with sound, and in listening, we discover ourselves enmeshed as well in those same elaborate patterns.

Thursday, May 7, 2015

#127

http://www.inspirationalstories.com/poems/dream-song-127-again-his-friend%255Cs-death-made-the-man-sit-still-john-berryman-poems/
 
Finally happened upon a very brief mention today that B. wrote 5 elegies to Randall Jarrell—DS 90 (obviously), 121 (ouch! How did I miss that?), 126, 127, and 259. So after pulling my hair out yesterday trying to figure out who the elegy was for, I got it wrong. Not T.S. Eliot—Randall Jarrell. Today, it’s still about Randall Jarrell.

One thing: It’s almost unbelievable how I got 121 so wrong, and it happened because I missed the reference to Randall Jarrell on the first line of the 2nd stanza. Kind of hard to miss, but I did it. Some are thinking, “I don’t like Berryman and don’t read the poems anyway,” and others are thinking, “I’ve haven’t yet understood more than a dozen lines anyway, so what does it matter?”, and others are thinking, “This kills your whole project. The blog is invalid. What a bonehead maneuver.” It was like Poe’s “The Purloined Letter”, where there is this critical piece of evidence in the form of a letter hidden in a Paris flat, which the police can’t find because it’s perched right there on the mantelpiece in plain sight. They’re looking under carpets and behind the wallpaper, but they don’t see the letter on the mantel. Yep. I knew I would probably miss a few things along the way, but this one is big, and a bit embarrassing. Oh, well, nobody’s watching… I have half a mind to go back and do 121 over, and I may just do that yet. It was a pretty spectacular rant, though, but totally spinning out of control. I can’t believe I missed it. Oh well… What worries me now is that the topic I hit on, in my misreading of the poem, says too much about something in me I maybe should have kept to myself? I need to put a paper bag over my head for a day and then try to forget about it. But, you know, take out that reference to RJ, and my response adds up to a consistent, persistent, focused, coherent, incisive, and insightful wrong reading! A brilliant screw up! Magnificent malarkey! Astonishing!!! (I think I’ll just tack this onto 121 and forget about it.) Feeling sheepish.

Embarrassment slides easily into regret then to grief. So, to move on. This poem is not hard to decipher. It’s plain, an expression of grief for the passing of a friend. It’s appropriate, doesn’t stretch any personal or societal boundaries of propriety, and is a simple statement that the writer is in grief. Same with yesterday’s 126. Not much to bellyache about. Bow my head and acknowledge that grief merits respect. Today, we lost someone at my school. A member of the grounds crew for 30 years here. He loved nurturing plants, took care of the campus with dedication and made it his baby, and was killed last night at home on his farm in a tractor accident. There was a simple and elegant prayer service for him today. He was widely liked. The trees, the flowers and the lawns on this campus were Jeff’s poetry.

Wednesday, May 6, 2015

#126 A Thurn

http://www.occupypoetry.net/dream_song_126_a_thurn

“Thurn” is not an English word. Thurn und Taxis was a German noble family that was prominent in the 16th century German postal service—which I first read about long ago in Thomas Pynchon’s The Crying of Lot 49, an odd, short, and really cool novel that actually engages with postal service intrigue in 16th century Europe, of all things, though there’s more to it than that. The Thurn und Taxis family grew into a long-lived line of German nobility and built a number of castles with their wealth. Thurn was a German variant of the Italian torre, for “tower,” and the details of the poem would seem lend credence to “tower” as the definition: It’s a meditation on death and legacy in contemplation of a marble grave marker in a place with many of them. More to the point, though, is who is lying beneath the grave marking the elegy?

The mention of the “Abbey” and the mention of Ben Johnson, and another Johnson, (maybe James Johnson, soldier and “Governor” of Quebec [he commanded the garrison for a time in the 1700s], or perhaps William Johnson, Sub-Almoner to King Charles II)—all three Johnsons interred in Westminster Abbey—place this poem in contemplation of somebody’s memorial in Westminster Abbey. It’s driving me crazy, but I cannot find a reference to who it is. My best guess, but who I think it must be, is that it’s T.S. Eliot, who died in 1965, and whose stone in Poet’s Corner of Westminster Abbey was unveiled in January, 1967. That’s the right time frame, and the references to the person’s “grandeur & mettle” seems to help (Eliot was a grand figure and probably mettlesome too, literarily speaking), and the repetition of “tiresome” in the 3rd stanza helps as well. Eliot’s is a poetry of magnificent exhaustion as much as anything, a modernist who dramatized the decline and dissolution of Western society’s strength, virility, relevance, and outright viability.

A thurn, then, is a tower, and the poem is an ode to the passing of a towering figure.

(This is a short post, but I’ve never had to work harder to unpuzzle a Dream Song, and I’m still not convinced beyond all doubt. I’m utterly exhausted…. In the words of Eliot’s J. Alfred Prufrock: “I grow old ... I grow old ... / I shall wear the bottoms of my trousers rolled.”)

Tuesday, May 5, 2015

#125

http://plagiarist.com/poetry/5705/

B. wrote this on a June afternoon in 1966, after signing up students for a summer course in Western masterpieces at the University of Minnesota. Apparently he saw them as a frivolous group of lightweights. According to B. in this poem, the initiation of old for being known as a bard entailed more than his students understood. It involved more than just writing. Probably you had to know how to play a harp and use a sword, and the freezing immersions of initiation he mentions tempered one’s resolve and one’s soul—all that kind of high-barbarian romance. Now, it’s all light and dry, as he claims, and maybe Poetry claimed a few young wannabes in the beatnik’s turtleneck-and-loafers uniform, though no one actually read their work. That’s still probably true: Poets mainly are read by other poets, though there are still careers to be made in literature, and the initiation for us isn’t that darned easy either, even if it’s different. Poets mainly have to be academics in order to eat—at least that’s the primary route our culture offers. Latin American cultures offer their poets positions as ambassadors, or at least they used to, which is kind of cool. But it takes a special kind of crazy commitment to write a Ph.D. dissertation, even an MFA thesis. A number of people do manage it, but it’s never easy. If hardly anyone one reads Ph.D. dissertations, well, neophyte bards sharpening themselves immersed in freezing bog water didn’t have much of an audience either. The point is to toughen up. Our culture inhales artistic expression anyway, we’ve just developed forms other than poetry: Rock, folk, country music, Hollywood films, television, computer games, Vine videos on YouTube, comic books, and plenty more. Much of it is schlock, but much that is artful and brilliant arises out of any form. And I’ll guarantee you as well that many an uninspired bard made the mead-guzzling blonde warriors in some oaken hall roll their eyes and groan at the clichés and bad verses being foisted off on them. Maybe they poured flagons of ale over the bad bards’ heads, I don’t know, swung axes past their ears or shot at them with crossbows. That’s still not as bad as a form rejection slip.

That last stanza: “I say the paralyzed fear lest one’s not one / is back with us forever.” This strikes me as quite the careerist statement. If you’re not known as “one of the ones,” in other words, the accolades and recognition aren’t flowing your way, then that’s paralyzing because what’s the point otherwise? There’s a little voice in me, let’s call her Violet, who would like to pipe up and in a squeaky little voice say that the spiritual reward of making is better than an avalanche of accolades, fame and wealth, because without that, the fame is substanceless and false. But Violet is like the storybook mouse I think I remember, possibly from a Rudyard Kipling story, who swears he will cross the middle of the room one of these days, but always ends up cowering near the wall.

Monday, May 4, 2015

#124

http://www.eliteskills.com/analysis_poetry/Dream_Song_124_Behold_I_bring_you_tidings_of_great_joy_by_John_Berryman_analysis.php

“Couvade” is the ritual of an “expectant” father sequestering himself as his wife is due to give birth, pantomiming the birth process, mimicking a response to the birth pangs, and even sometimes (reportedly) actually experiencing them. It has been reported in cultures worldwide, though in our culture we don’t hear much about it. Perhaps it’s because fathers are often present at births now, though in B.’s time that was less common. In his day, you had an ersatz, comic form of couvade in the stereotype of the nervous father pacing up and down the hospital hallways, making a nuisance of himself, probably smoking nonstop and pulling now and then from a flask of bourbon tucked in his pocket. There are still reports of sympathetic pregnancies on the parts of fathers, of course. I know women who scoff openly, derisively, at such nonsense, so maybe it’s best to let that sleeping dog lie. Sympathetic psychosomatic hysteria be damned!

Here’s my version of the perfect Hell: Stuff an infinite lineup of freezers with meat, have Mephistopheles throw the switch on an Infernal power outage, and a week or so later, give me the task of cleaning them out, one by one for eternity, while an endless loop of Frank Sinatra tunes blare from fuzzed-out tinny speakers overhead. Sure, the stench of the rotting meat would be bad enough, but it’s Ol’ Blue Eyes that has this rendition of Perdition making my flesh crawl even as I imagine it. I simply do not get why everybody thinks he’s so all-fired great. I’ve always thought Sinatra was a total phony-baloney. The Rat Pack mystique does nothing for me. But I think my conception of Sinatra really got poisoned by the film I stumbled into one Saturday afternoon, that was just playing to itself on TV in the background until it caught my attention. The film was called Lady in Cement. Sinatra’s character, Tony Rome, a hard-boiled detective, is scuba diving in search of sunken treasure when he happens on a beautiful dead blond woman under the water, in a bikini, of course, drowned and with her feet encased in cement. This begins some sort of search for the perpetrators, and organized crime is somehow implicated, on and on—cretinous bullshit of the cheapest order. It’s the one scene that I actually stopped and watched before I switched the set off that got me. A nude model, posing in an artist’s studio. She needs a bathroom break. “Johnny, I gotta go to the bathroom.” “Shut up and sit still,” says the artist. “But Johnny, I gotta go to the bathroom!” On like that for too long, until finally it’s Sinatra who gives her permission to get off the stool and visit the ladies room. It may be the most sordid, the most infuriating thing I’ve ever seen in a film. The misogynistic derision is pretty obvious, and I’ve run into individuals in my life with all manner of variation on the same attitude. What especially insults my sensibility is that this was put to film.

Mistakes get made in the decision process of corporate filmmaking all the time. This was no mistake. This was consistent and symptomatic of a deep, culturally embedded, institutionalized misogyny. It didn’t even have anything to do with the plot. It was a scene of gratuitous humiliation of a female character. It has its predecessors. My wife used to like Doris Day movies when she was a kid, but when we watched them again, we were stunned by the messages all of them carry: The perky, spunky blonde, like some precocious child, eventually always gets shown her place, and if it takes Rock Hudson to put her over his knee and spank her, then so much the better.

Lady in Cement has been relegated to the dumpster of our cultural history, at least, where it belongs. It was made in 1968. It’s a bad movie. I wouldn’t even want to recycle it. No one watches Doris Day movies anymore, for the same reasons. These films pick up on and express something that, in retrospect, has to appear shameful. We have other cultural shames in our past, and Berryman comes down sometimes on the defensible side of them. DS 10, for example, is such a great comment on one of those cultural disgraces, and it’s the kind of thing that has kept me going. He walks a fine line on race in other ways, but let’s keep that at bay.

This one—I don’t know. It begins with “I bring you tidings of great joy” which is of course from the Gospel of Luke, spoken by the angels announcing Jesus’s birth to the shepherds. I wonder if B. isn’t rather quoting Linus from the Charlie Brown Christmas special, but no matter. Either way, the meaning is clear enough. (Linus’s reading of Luke is among the most beautiful and moving moments American television has ever produced anyway.) B.’s son has been born. (In real life, his son was born in 1956, and his daughters in 1962 and 1965, so I think the poem might be a dream. Also, no matter.) But the key line in the first stanza: “Henry is delivered.” My first reaction? Uh-oh. You’ve got to be kidding me. Does this not seem like a bit of an egocentric pronouncement? Henry has been delivered? Of what? Well, okay, he’s worried about his wife and baby, and when they’re pronounced safe and healthy, there’s a relief involved. Me: Not quite buying it here. But I do get the second stanza—fathers as ancillary to the birth process, a bit player. I was present when my son was born, and except for him by and by, I was the only male in the delivery room. Two doctors, three or four nurses running in and out, mom, and the prevailing atmosphere from all these busy professional women presiding over a very difficult birth was, You may stay here, but keep the hell out of the way. Well, no problem with that. I was completely out of my depth and sensible enough to admit it. They all handled the crisis like the pros they were. Finally they handed me my newborn son, I looked into his face and thought, Oh my God! It’s my Aunt Lola!

It’s the third stanza here that takes such a weird turn. Henry has made it through his own egotistical (seems to me) couvade; it’s egotistical because it places emphasis on him. The couvade can possibly be seen as a sympathetic response to labor, but I rather think it’s a means of focusing everything that accompanies birth—struggle, pain, and especially the accolades that follow a successful birth—onto the father, at the expense of the mother. And that falls right in line with the misogyny I’ve been worrying about. John Stuart Mill wrote an essay called “On the Subjection of Women” where he wonders what has given rise to the subjugation of women. He thinks about men’s early response to women through their mothers and writes, “He sees that she is superior to him, and believes that, notwithstanding her superiority, he is entitled to command and she is bound to obey. What must be the effect on his character, of this lesson?” Men are thrown into an existential bind from the beginning, according to him. And the observance of the elemental importance of childbirth later on only reinforces the bind. In other words, everything in my world shows me that women are to be subject to my command, yet my observations seem to show that she is superior in many important ways. The response to the conundrum is to resent that which causes it. I think there are probably some issues with Mills’s thesis, but give him some credit. He wrote that in 1856. One would like to think that by 1966, or so, some progress in questioning the root-level assumptions that Mills makes, and that carry forward, might have been undertaken. Not yet for everybody. The growing pressure of feminism, a revolution of sorts, as I touched on a day or two ago, would give rise to a counter-pressure. Humiliate her. Do violence. But don’t let her think she’s getting her way. And in the case of this couvade business, steal her thunder. Take the accolades and make them yours, not because you deserve them, but because you think you should deserve them.

And the castrating business, and prying the severed “dongs” along with her teeth from her mouth with a crowbar? Whew. That’s difficult, difficult stuff to contemplate. Well, at least the agony of the couvade is better than that other ritual he comes up with, where women will, you know, do that thing they’ll do if you just relax long enough to let them…

Oh, horse hockey! Why even mention it? I got fed up with the castration business before, and who on earth are these people anyway who are so insecure in their manhood that they fear castration and do violence as a kind of pre-emptive defense against the fantasies they’re so terrified of?

It’s bigger than our intrepid, cowering poet, I’ll say that much. Kerouac’s On the Road is full of condescension toward women, a few of Hemingway’s utterances, like “The Short, Happy Life of Francis Macomber”, are inexcusable, and the post-war literary landscape, especially, is full of this stuff. And then there’s Hollywood. And the Rat Pack. It’s the counterforce, in action, isn’t it? Eventually, feminism in its next wave made some strides, and I hope I can say that it has influenced my conception for the better regarding what it means to have been born a man. So, I have trouble seeing this poem as anything other than a shining monument, one of many similar cultural artifacts, to a broad, deep, male-gendered cowardice.

Sunday, May 3, 2015

#123

http://www.americanpoems.com/poets/john-berryman/5632

All artists have been here. Some days you’ve got it, and some days you don’t. Here’s Over the Rhine, one of my favorite musical acts, on this phenomenon: “And it's got nothing to do with me / The wind blows through the trees / But if I look for it, it won't come / I tense up, my mind goes numb / There's nothing harder than learning how to receive.” You can try what Hemingway suggested: Write one true sentence. (Isn’t that just so Hemingway, by the way?) Sure. OTR suggests it’s about learning to open and receive, which assumes something arriving from either outside of your consciousness or from below it. A modern, post-mythological take on the presence of the Muse. Hemingway soldiers on, forcing the creation anyway of a “true” result, no matter how small. You can think of it either way, or, like me, just build small abstract sculptures out of paper clips, thumbtacks, and the little springs that fall out of ballpoint pens when you screw them open.

In writing as much poetry in the past four months as in the 25 years previous, I’ve found that writing poetry is actually much more difficult and much more taxing than writing prose, and when you finish a poem, you have to understand that there will be a few days of emptiness before the well fills again. In spite of my impatience with the sociopolitical impropriety of B.’s chauvinism from yesterday, he was still a heck of a prolific poet, and a very good one. He was zoned. But the zone only means that you’re ready to do the work. You still have to push, and it’s heavy. The zone provides a context in readiness for the work. The effort is up to you. Discipline and preparedness make you more fit for the job, but it takes the same effort. He was driven to work his ass off.

The problem is that if so much of ones sense of self-worth and justification for eating is predicated on that work progressing, then the inevitable days that arrive when the work refuses to unfold feel like death more than for most people. It should be healthy to on occasion just say screw it, and go mow the lawn. B. would mostly get drunk, believing that the rush of booze through his veins carried the inspiration along with it. Booze forestalled imaginative death, in other words, even as it hastened the onset of the physical one. There’s the problem right there in separating the body from the spirit. From what I’ve heard, heroin-addicted be bop jazz artists were big into chemical inspiration, finding out they were mistaken only when it was too late. It has always seemed to me that if you listen to Crosby, Stills & Nash’s “Wooden Ships” closely, a great, great song, you can hear the cocaine just streaming through it. Maybe the booze did motivate Berryman, or maybe just believing it did made the difference. However it happened, he worked hard. This poem has a kind of paradox woven through it. It moves seamlessly from blockage or exhaustion into death and decay, and the movement is understandable for one whose life really only matters when the work is progressing. To not work is death. It leads to a really nice moment in the poem: “These men have access. Sleepless, in position, / they dream the past forever.” They have access, now, don’t they? B., with death figuratively looming as well, finds his inspiration in writing about not having any inspiration; he finds life in death approaching. He writes about not being able to write, and it resulted in one of my favorite Dream Songs so far.

Saturday, May 2, 2015

#122

http://www.americanpoems.com/poets/john-berryman/5631

While it would be nearly impossible (for me, anyway) to track down specifically what this poem is referring to, it doesn’t matter. The clues in the text lay out a narrative: Poem published, critical attack, Henry succumbs, lies down in a grave while the critical dogs of the world bay at his corpse and pee on his headstone. Something like that.

Doggedly one writes on. He did it. I’m doing it. But I’m awash in reservations today. I’m going to quote from a review of a collection of critical essays, from one of his former students, which captures my misgivings, for this day, over this whole project I jumped into. I swing back and forth. This is a “back” day, feeling fed up with narcissism in all its guises. To quote: “After decades of living with him, so to speak, I have come to regard him as a spoiled brat.” He came to class drunk and smoking, shivering and sweating, having been shepherded there from the rehab hospital by a caretaker, who would escort him straight back. He bullied his students, celebrated the bullies and narcissists and near-criminals in the class, ignoring or ridiculing the others. This report was toward the end, the professor having been eviscerated by decades of relentless substance abuse. In spite of it all, when he got on a roll, he was electric.

In this poem, he looks to be getting all maudlin and drama-boy about one of his poems that got criticized, and you know, jerk he could be, if he “published his girl’s bottom” in the staid pages of an old weekly—and, wait, excuse me, published his girl’s bottom? What does that even mean? The potential for a misogynistic reading of that line is almost breathtaking, but there it is, and if there’s a resultant criticism of the atavistic jerkitude such a statement seems to be exposing, well go figure, huh? DS 113, another reviewer claims, is a record of one of his early classroom encounters with feminism. I didn’t pick that up, but no one else does either. But, maybe the drunken old boys of literary fame’s first rank from back in the day, of which he was a card-carrying member of the club, found all that incipient feminism a bit disconcerting. When revolution starts building pressure, the status quo power usually attempts to screw down the lid. If women are in the next stage of saying “enough!”, then humiliation of them has utility as a counter-force. Publish them girls’ bottoms, go ahead. That’ll teach her. This gets under my skin today.

My intention in this blog, really out of sheer ignorance, was to pull these poems and my responses to them in my direction—like, it’s my blog. I’ve done some and I’ll do more of that. But I’m aware today that there’s a kind of sordid magnificence to The Dream Songs in the aggregate that I was completely innocent of, but that has its own horrible draw and power and is difficult to overcome. But they’re still sordid. This sickens me some. The only thing that saves them at all is that they’re frankly sordid. On one level there’s a “screw you if you don’t like it” ethic, but at the same time there’s this disgraceful groveling in response to criticism, which folds right back in to the “screw you” and leavens it further, so that disgrace is held out as a challenge and a tormented virtue. “You think that’s disgraceful? Just watch this, fucker.” That kind of thing. Geez. As long as you write about it, anything goes. And what weirds it all beyond belief is that this is not just all floating out there some fiction in language and in print. It’s lived. It’s embodied in the person, it’s the foundation for the poetry. The art feeds the living madness, which feeds the art, and it takes on an emergent form like a tornado. There is no life for its own sake. That got shot early. The poet’s life matters most in abject subjection to the art.

The other thing that saves it is that life and the 60s have some pretty sordid details. Do we wallow in it? I’ve tried three times to read Naked Lunch because of its infamy, and because I wanted to read the scene that inspired Steely Dan’s name, the best damn musical act of the 70s (along with Joni Mitchell, for different reasons). I never made it to Steely Dan because the nausea of that novel overwhelms me every time I stick my nose in it. I understand that it matters as a novel because the record of the sickened, ruined, magnificent imagination of the heroin addict is compelling, and there are apparently enough readers out there with the stomach to endure the thing. Not me. I came up short, and I have no intention of trying Naked Lunch a fourth time. Now, I’m getting the connection between Naked Lunch and The Dream Songs, the life-record of the brilliant, devastated alcoholic destroying himself who nevertheless maintains windows of feverish clarity where he lays it all out there. DS 46 stands out as among the great poems in English, I think. Many of the others meld into a long, stifling recording of the squirmings of a self-abusive, narcissistic, misogynistic, demonic Peter Pan. But you know what? We have a world full of these people, don’t we? Biography, history, literature, and philosophy, I have this dopey expectation that they ennoble us. Sometimes instead they get dragged right down into the mud and the horse dung. Whether they ennoble the dung or not, I’m not ready yet to say, but I got a nose full of it. One last thing: Apparently, when B. finally jumped from a bridge, his final poetic gesture, the autopsy revealed that the fall wasn’t what killed him. He suffocated from his face buried in the mud. Figures. Reading that detail today is what triggered this whole rant. Now, I’m glad that’s off my chest. Time to go somewhere and breathe. It’s spring out there, after all.

Friday, May 1, 2015

#121

http://www.best-poems.net/john_berryman/dream_song_121_grief_is_fatiguing_he_is_out_of_it.html

I so get this poem. I remember as a youngster when I would run into some new pretty girl, or she had been there all along and I just noticed her, and uh-oh, here came the crush, and all I could think was, “Oh noooo. Not this again. Nooooo.” I absolutely dreaded it. There was never any stopping the emotional train bearing down, me tied to the tracks by the ropes of my stupid merciless feelings. I hated it, and I really, really hated it. I resented it. Had I been a bit more confident or experienced, this might have been something to revel in and enjoy. It seemed to be—sometimes—for other people. Girls did not seem much interested though. When they grew into women, everything suddenly changed, and it was baffling. But that’s another story.

That’s what’s going on here. Henry falls half in love with one of his students and “the sad process continues to the whole / as it swarmed & began”. Here it comes. Shit. And that’s the grief of the first line that is so fatiguing to the speaker—unrequited or inexpressible desire always morphs to grief. It’ll wear you out.

But here’s the thing: When you’re thirteen or fourteen, crushes lumber along out of nowhere and devastate everybody. They’re like giant meteorites, they just come streaking out of the blue and obliterate whatever they crash into. That’s part of being a young teenager. It comes with the territory. But when you’re fifty?

I’m already close to end of this episode of Romantic soul-baring, but I need to add this. You do notice your students. They’re young and beautiful and smart and lively, and you have eyes. What’s not to love? And since we’re all 13 years old down deep, the same old potential for a wounding crush lurks in the depths of anyone’s heart. But the accumulated layers of maturity suppress all that, and there is more control as well. It’s not that we don’t have the same passions in our fifties, it’s that we have more safeguards and more controls, we’re wiser and nimbler and more solid. This business doesn’t break the surface and gain control. We have families and people emotionally dependent on us being present, and that's who we care about and who we want to care about. Our responsibilities matter more. So you shrug it off. This is what’s called being well-adjusted. The only reason I would even talk about this now is because John Berryman threw it out there, and I’ve set myself the task of responding to whatever shows on a given day. Some days are easier than others.

Well adjusted? He wasn’t very well adjusted, was he? Maybe. Actually—of course he wasn’t  very well adjusted! Not by the definition I just laid out, as having the ability to relegate one’s renegade feelings to the dungeon of societal expectations where they ebb away, dying from leprosy, starvation and loneliness. I did write about this whole thing in a story once, and the main character, talking with his beautiful young niece about what one does with inadmissible feelings, tells her he that he wraps them in duct tape and stuffs them into the back of the bottom dresser drawer. That’s what a middle-aged man is expected to do. You can’t have creepy old geezer professors mooning in the open over their students. Most of them would run away to puke anyway, but some are too fragile, unsure, vulnerable. They’re young, they need space to screw up and develop, find their own foolish way with other clumsy young people and figure it out. They depend on the freedom to be awkward.

In practice? It doesn’t always work. Some can wrap up those feelings and tuck them away, but sometimes they jerk open the drawer from the inside and splinter the whole damn dresser to flinders. Age’s experience and the expectations of propriety are powerless to suppress it. The harder you try, the more thundering the eventual explosion. Other times, here they come oozing out from under the dresser, making a mess on the floor like an oily puddle of greenish-black petroleum that you can’t just wipe up. We all know this. So I’ll give the poet credit on this poem for something. It’s a poet’s job to engage with this business, as icky and uncomfortable as it might be to us well-adjusted folks. He takes the risk. Wrinkled, nostrils stuffed with hair, never loved his body anyway—hardly the virile young Romeo his lovely young students are probably pining for—his heart still pulses and oozes, because living hearts always pulse and ooze. It’s a real fucking mess, too. But there it is. Credit for artistic courage on this one, not grotesque exhibitionism. It’s not to say he should have permission to act on these flowings of love and desire for girls too young for him. The societal reasons for keeping this business out of the actionable everyday window seem valid. His act is to write about it, shunt the business off in a less inappropriate direction. It’s not a crime anymore, it’s art. It’s safe now, and we can finally admit that even as sensible adults we know exactly what he’s talking about.

(Addendum, added May 7: It’s almost unbelievable how I got 121 so wrong, and it happened because I missed the reference to Randall Jarrell on the first line of the 2nd stanza. Kind of hard to miss, but I did it. Some are thinking, “I don’t like Berryman and don’t read the poems anyway,” and others are thinking, “I’ve haven’t yet understood more than a dozen lines anyway, so what does it matter?”, and others are thinking, “This kills your whole project. The blog is invalid. What a bonehead maneuver.” It was like Poe’s “The Purloined Letter”, where there is this critical piece of evidence in the form of a letter hidden in a Paris flat, which the police can’t find because it’s perched right there on the mantelpiece in plain sight. They’re looking under carpets and behind the wallpaper, but they don’t see the letter on the mantel. Yep. I knew I would probably miss a few things along the way, but this one is big, and a bit embarrassing. Oh, well, nobody’s watching… I have half a mind to go back and do 121 over, and I may just do that yet. It was a pretty spectacular rant, though, but totally spinning out of control. I can’t believe I missed it. Oh well… What worries me now is that the topic I hit on, in my misreading of the poem, says too much about something in me I maybe should have kept to myself? I need to put a paper bag over my head for a day and then try to forget about it. But, you know, take out that reference to RJ, and my response adds up to a consistent, persistent, focused, coherent, incisive, and insightful wrong reading! A brilliant screw up! Magnificent malarkey! Astonishing!!! [I think I’ll just tack this onto 121 and forget about it.] Feeling sheepish.)